00:00

We started this. There were about a quarter million. Distributors internet comes along. Everybody is afraid that the internet is going to disintermediate all sale distribution Yes. In this country, Amazon comes along changes the value. Add the key value out is they could buy boxes and break them into each of us and sell them effectively.

Hmm. Amazon kind of took that whole somatic approach and that's no longer it's table Stakes. Now, there are but it's not true value.

Today there are almost 250,000 everything in this room. If you look around here from the ceiling tiles to the carpet. Yeah, I'll lie to the plants The lamps. Everything is probably come through, a distributor, the world of distribution has morphed the level and type of value. Add is different than it was 20 years ago, but there's still two hundred fifty thousand Distributors out there.

And there are 109 sub sectors of distribution. We will look at any of those hundred nine sub-segments, regardless of the economy was going on. On Define those jewels in those gems. And we try not to chase the shiny objects. We stay in the areas that were very comfortable with because we know that we can truly add value.

Vijay Grayson from supply chain equity on the podcast today. It was a fun episode because we took a few different angles, angles that we don't often get a chance to explore pursue. So we talked a bit about having a very disciplined rubric when evaluating business is, Jay is very concentrated supply chain Equity.

Obviously, they're focused on the supply chain working on distribution companies. We also talked a bit about constraints and how constraints actually can be a bit of a lever for business. Changes your orientation and thinking we also got in sort of the macro, the macro had the macro impacts the micro of his industry.

We talked about Supply chains have been impacted by what I call the death of globalism tariffs, those kinds of things. Pretty interesting discussion from someone who really understands lives and breathes this stuff has since the 1990s, that's a long time ago. So Jays incredibly informed on that and then we all close the discussion talking about babies.

My guidance for sellers again, Jay was investment banker before he was a private Equity guy, and before that he was an operator. So he has Real views on what sellers can do to prepare for a transaction years in advance. So I think there was a lot to mind from this conversation and a bit of a Nuance that we hadn't explored before.

Hopefully you guys get a lot of this episode, I certainly did.

Welcome to closing remarks. I'm your host dhara Sharif and we have with us today. Jay Grayson Jay, please introduce yourself. You can do our audience Xterra.

My name is Jay. Grayson, I'm a founding partner at supply chain Equity. We are still to this day. The only private Equity Fund that invest exclusively in the distribution and supply chain industry have now invested in 57, different distribution, businesses since 2006. And I appreciate the opportunity to share some thoughts.

With your audience to our, thank you. Yeah, we're excited to have you. So I think the themes I want to focus on today because we've had other buyers on. We've had a lot of sellers on and we found that it's when were thematic, it's more valuable to an audience of business owners and their spouses.

So I think the themes I want to focus on with you guys. One is discipline discipline as a strength. You guys are very narrowing, your focus and the other is constraints and there's a really interesting book that was just published

earlier this summer by David Epstein. In, it's called it's called constraints and I think the power of constraints inside the box, I think that is what it's called in the power of constraints. He did a great book called range earlier and really it's about sort of the limitations you place in herself.

Is an absolute like unlock, he talked about General magic, which is a cool company from the 80s. They assembled the best and most talented folks on the planet. And they were incredibly well funded before they did anything. And by the way, for the record, I do, remember General, man You do okay, of course.

Well, we're both of a simple array. Age. So we would remember that and they did nothing. They never got off the ground and kept on iterating and iterating on the product. But those folks took so many lessons out of that process and when they left, they stood up things like the iPhone and you know where the ring door and doorbell and those kinds of incredible incredible stuff and like just a quick diatribe here.

So the guy who set up ring, who was on that staff, he said here's the thing, we're going to create a constraint and that's the box.

Do whatever you want with this ring camera. It's got a fit in this box. So all these cool ideas they had, if they couldn't jam it into this one box, I designed it wasn't going to be there. And that was that limitation that constraint opened up opened up like a world that they had never envisioned before.

05:00

And that's how these guys built afterwards.

Really sort of your superpower. It may you may miss out on some sexy opportunities, but I think it's probably the unlock for you guys I love you. Got you just sort of explain a bit about the origin story of supply chain Equity. You know why? You're so focused on supply chain, which is obviously, so critical to the economy.

Yeah, yeah. It's an interesting origin story Darrell.

Being started and running either, the country's first Investment Banking practice focused on distribution businesses because back then everybody was a generalist. Yeah. The thought of Industry practices, just see didn't really seem to be take off, take off. Well, we had done two three, and then four distribution businesses learned about the industry.

And we decided to focus on that practice.

And so we did Investment Banking. We probably advise somewhere 40 45 companies or so when the sell their businesses.

Which is, you know, is it at about a 12-month process online start to finish when you do that, we did that from the late 90s until

about 2006. At which time we broke off from the investment Banks Investment Bank. We're at we started our own investment bag and really the end goal do was to drive that investment bank until such time that we had a private Equity business going.

So that was from about 2006 to about two Thousand Eleven or twelve where there was overlap. we started dedicating our teams to just the private Equity side in 2006. So where do you go when you're a first-time private Equity Firm to raise capital?

And no one is doing this in distribution. We went back to all of the owners of the businesses whom we have working it sold and and pitched. The idea of, you know, look, we'd like to start investing into the industry that, you know. Well, you can be an investor, you can, you can participate.

Just your knowledge of the industry they've been doing this for Generations Yeah. Sometimes and before you get off the phone call, they're like, you know, that's great. Thanks for selling our business, but we can also only golf fish and Hunt so much and if I have to be home for another six months without spouse men and males and females there.

Yeah, they that's great Let's do this. There's going to be murder on the scene if Will is gonna be murder on that. So it took about 18 months to get all the cats hurt her but that's that is how we started.

Eight former CEOs that were our lead investors and then we had institutions for some of the deeper money. Now, over time we become on the funds, get larger dollars, get larger. I think at last count, we had 36 or 38 former CEOs of some businesses. So, all we do is invest in distribution businesses, our network of, in our access to customers and vendors and the top consultants.

And just our internal knowledge here. Is We Believe on? Anything out in the market. So, I would think it'd be easier to raise that first fund. When you're going to folks, who you've unlocked sort of an illiquid asset and created, a liquid asset for them and saying, hey just take a little of the money that I helped you unlock and give it back to us so that we can deploy in an area that you actually understand.

And it is definitely that. And what's helpful there is when you're raising Capital, there has to be trust.

And businesses, you need to find people to trust that you're honest. The highest degree of Integrity that we is first and foremost in everything we do. And then we understand the distribution business and we know how to be good partners to the sellers in the honors. And that's what got us started.

And I said in 57, distribution deals later.

We're still going strong. And you have a really informed LP base at that point. So it isn't like you have any dumb money.

Specifically, smart money. That's got to be helpful to you. You leverage them, very early, as a bit of a de facto Advisory Board, obviously they have a say in terms of like an LP committee, but are they and where they involved did you run things by them? Because of their discipline and their and their access.

So yes and yes and we did it in a formal fashion and an informal fashion. Yeah it was the private Equity Fund. We have a formal Advisory Board in which some of our largest institutions in individual.

Or sit on, and that's just for, for structure in strong advisors, we input, but where the real strength of business is think about not just the 30-something feet. Yo, former CEOs, we have think about their networks, right? And, you know, we've worked with the people in their businesses, so we know their top executive team, who maybe they were sales managers

10:00

of the time the sale, and now they're running a different business. Yeah.

Current and the Consultants because we worked all the top distribution, consultants in the industry, we can literally get to any vendor or any customer if we don't have a relationship with them today in one or two phone calls, so really shortens the degree of separation. And that's what allows us.

I think it's part of our secret sauce yet. I would think it would create. And listen, I, this is a word that gives current, I cringe. When I have to say, it out loud proprietary deal flow because as a sell side Investment Bank, we want to make sure there's not a lot of that out there.

He's everything we can't but I would think if even though it's hard to find it, you would have access because of a network knowing folks who may be contemplating a sale. Is that part of the strategy also to leverage that Network? Absolutely. And you all due respect to the investment banking community, that we appreciate another critical to our business.

You know, our goal like most private Equity Funds to try to see about a fine businesses that are off market. So to speak and our approach is is quite different. We're looking for owners.

That really looking for a true partner to help get their business to the next level.

When we talk about adding value and hopefully, in this podcast, we can get into a little bit of that because I think it's important just to help private Equity has shifted. Yeah. In the last 10 years, but it's always been our Mantra. How do we truly add value to a business Financial engineering spreadsheets?

Don't add real value. No, that's not. The world were in and really, that's kind of our, that's our Focus there. So I'd love to get into it now.

Your when someone who actually does it every day, says it. I think there's a misconception out there.

Now, a lot of it is is a result of actual lived experiences. You think back to the 80s, right? When private Equity really started to become known and you've read, Barbie are barbarians at the gate, and you seem leverage balance sheets on both side, the target being leveraged, the actual, the acquirer being leveraged and you're sort of financially, engineering your way to a successful.

A successful outcome.

That's not the world of private Equity today.

us who buy companies today, that are private Equity Funds are looking to add value, they're looking they're backing management teams, they're not, they're not eviscerating them, they're adding to the sales team. They're trying to drive incremental value through value, creation, strategies, and not looking for a way to sort of lever It up.

Use very little cash. They're looking for a way to make the company better. Not just create this sort of on paper Financial engineering project, right? So, I'd love to hear your view on value creation.

Create value in the portfolio company. So I'm a smiling a little bit. He had our because that's all we've known from from the day, we started, you know, are investing process. It's truly adding value. And basically, we were taught how to be good value. Add Partners to owners and management teams by Guess Who former CEOs?

Right that we worked for they they have taught us. Well what real true partnership means and look to be very Frank.

Every private Equity Firm talks about adding value outside of the spreadsheet. Work is still a relatively small percent. In our opinion that are truly coming in and adding value just because you have a Playbook this is you can wreak some boxes in to apply a standard playbook in any industry that's out there and think you're going to be successful you know I would call call into question so where we try to add value?

We've been doing nothing but this in distribution. Lucien from the late 90s on the south side and the investment side since 2006. So everything that we do is focused on just the distribution world, this the nuances of a company and the people and the investment, and the Cadence of which you can do things, or should do things in that business that really determine whether you're going to be successful or not, trying to go too fast and you can, you can actually hurt a platform.

And if it's like trying to build on a house of cards, right going to make sure the house is strong before you start. Invest in some really strong growth initiatives, a lot of time, we're going in, and we're doing blocking and tackling with structuring of the Salesforce, we're helping them with an Erp implementation, a CRM, implementation other, it type work, helping them bolster the executive team if, and if, and when they need it, right?

And make sure we've got a really strong platform upon which to build, and then we can start to execute more The Playbook going forward, but we're very careful in the balance of not going too fast But then, of course, not. Going to slow you given the nature of what we do as investors.

You have the sort of an operating methodology. I mean, you talked about a bit of a Playbook and I know if anyone could have a Playbook that would likely work with would be you guys because you are so disciplined and narrowing your focus versus the fund that has his operational Playbook that you know they're going to they're opportunistic and they would try to apply it to almost any number of Industries.

15:00

So do you have like a framework that you guys focus on? Or is it more of a bespoke playbook for each opportunity?

There's a framework of things that we can do, the the nuances, what is appropriate to do for this type of business. And when and in what sequence and that's really the key when we first start with investment, I think we do something. It's, you know, somewhat unique is we don't even go in with a form to board.

So we will sit down with the the owner assuming the owners continue going forward and has rolled over into the business and the executive team. Mmmmm will then go into our Network. It may be some of our investors and may not be but we'll say who are the best people that could potentially add value to this business as a board member do we need product expertise, do we need to go to market strategy?

Expertise is this more of an IT play? What are we trying to accomplish here?

And then who could be the best board members? We lock ourselves in a room or and we'll let's say we need, you know to board members.

Or and I'll sit in their room and go through a strategic planning process. When we come out of that two or three day process, everybody has collectively agreed on. What are these key strategic growth initiatives? Because we're growth investors, our job is to is to partner with management help accelerate growth.

That's the lens. We look at everything through dark.

So we come out of that meeting with a very strong understanding of mission confirmation you strategies, and then start to work on those tactics.

And during those meetings, we see how the respective board members are interacting, how the management is comfortable with them and then coming out of the meeting, it becomes self apparent. Where some of these folks in there are they the right fit overall and they'll know it in the management team will know it.

And then coming out of that. That's usually how we select our board. And by definition that board that is aligned with the mission strategy and tactics that we just spent two and a half days allowing ourselves on. That makes so much sense. But that on this podcast where I've come into a board and very quickly identified some sort of holes in the board.

And this was not always when I was an investor, I was in a, in a past life. I was a VC for about 10 years.

As I've said, I'm in complete recovery. I have not a VC anymore or anyone who thinks I am You did this backwards. Maybe we did it the right way and I did it back exactly why. I still get business plan set to me and I mean, I haven't been a PC in 15 years, but when I used to join a board, I would always

Skills that we had amongst the board members and then over time, I develop Okay. Here's where I think we need in terms of overall skills and they do the Gap analysis, right? And we, we need here is a hole here, as a whole. We need someone who really can understand to finance function when it gets big, you know.

So then we need that we need. Someone who's got some HR expertise, we need these four things, these are a holes and then start recruiting for those four holes. And and that, that was always how I looked at it as an outside board member and you guys take that and put it on on steroids, which

Your time, I sit in the public company board and if you look at the nacd National Association of corporate directors, they actually do a really good job in a functional skills. Matrix in a way that you try to analyze the board every year you were way ahead of it as of the curve and we use some of those Cape, we use some of those tactics in our board so it's informal but it's also the end of day formal.

What are we trying to accomplish? But only piece of paper and we're saying who has the skill sets.

The way we think is going to be a good partner with the management team. It's so important and it, frankly, I don't know that it was that evolved thinking as much as like being kind of simplistic in my view I think it's, you're just, you're just a team, right? I mean, you just a strategic team.

It's like, it's like running any team like work. What do you what do you need on this team in terms of creating the right outputs, okay, what do we have on the team right now? And just do it that I was trained to be a consultant 30 years ago? It's like what this do that Gap analysis Okay, what are we missing?

Let's go, let's go recruit for that It's okay.

All different, but not that different as you would know as well as anybody. So, it sounds to me like, you guys are, you know, you're a fund, you accumulate Capital, you have LPS, you have institutional investors your mole that so you are a fun. I'm sure you have the 2 and 20 or whatever.

The mailing numbers are today standard combat Exactly.

But you operate almost like a sort of laissez strategic investor versus a sort of a financial investor that dude. We distinguish. So, we talk about the world of financials and that's the private Equity, that's a family office, that's individual, buyers, and Independence sponsors, and all those folks, and then you have a strategic, which is just an operating company who's either entered in your industry, or somewhere in the value chain, or value, chain slightly away.

But someone who come in as an operating company and, and they see it as a valuable addition to the business, but they're not a buyer

20:00

professionally, right? You're a professional buyer.

Ot giuk, not just someone who has institutional knowledge you as an operating partner, you guys. Are you live and breathe this one thing every day all day.

It's right. And now it's yeah we joke about ourselves we don't have to be in aren't necessarily the sharpest tools in the shed. Yeah but if you do something over and over again you get pretty good at it and I'm still in all of a lot of my compatriots in private Equity. There are over 10,000 private Equity firms out there.

And over 20,000 if you include hedge funds and VT and SUVs and search funds and everything out there that are looking at all different types of businesses.

That's a tough but the way we look at it so we try to stay very focused on that but we are very much a strategic because again, 57 investments in the distribution supply chain world. So we will look at you know, when the world is really when they're a lot of businesses out there for sale at our Peak we look at over 300 deals a year to do.

Do one platform and some add-ons. So we're very, we are bottom of the funnel is very, very tidy, what we look to do, because we're looking for the right partnership, the right opportunity, you know, so one to two platforms looking at all those beers is as our operating basis, but again, it's all distribution.

So we look at everything like a strategic. We even tell our investors, we don't have the classic defined hold period.

First five years, typically wrapping a fund up after 10 years but we had the ability to have extensions in there. Yeah. If we think the opportunity is right, and we've never had any and we've used the lots of extensions. We've never had any LP, not even a single one rather than needing 80% of them to agree to it.

The say no, because they understand their, our job is to figure out when is the right time to invest, when's the right Cadence to add value one. Does it look like the right opportunity to exit the business? By the way? Something we do. I think very differently, dhara is every exit we have ever had starts with the executive team, hmm.

It's when the market is in a situation where they believe either because they're looking at their personal profits interests or stock that they own. As we make sure everybody has an investment the business. Although the leadership team of the key people as well, when they are looking at and saying you don't, maybe this is a good time to take some chips off the table.

What does that mean? How do we do that?

It's our process. Now we're talking throughout the life of a whole period of what we're seeing in the market. When we think it may be a good time to consider that, but we don't pull the trigger without full management team support. So you talked about a couple things that really resonate with me.

So the first is the notion of repetitions like the folks who listen to this podcast Faithfully will know that. That's one of the things that I think is the most important thing.

Well, I don't think we are the smartest people doing this work, but I know we get more reps than you.

And it's because of the repetitions that builds the muscle that, you know, we are better than anyone at the practice of MMA in the lower Middle Market. There's no one better at it because we get more reps than anybody. The 220 deals last year and I think that it's the, it's the Reps that build that sort of know that muscle and the callous.

And I wonder if that sort of builds in for you guys because you have a very similar orientation conviction and confidence in your decision making algorithm like that. You, you have this conviction that weird. We know what we're doing and you never stray. It isn't like, you see, I you see a shiny object over there and it's like, oh it became a unicorn?

Well damn, I miss that one. I don't sense you ever kind of do that Monday morning quarterbacking where it's like you had an opportunity to do this a steel and you knew it was probably a pretty good one because you're a smart guy but it doesn't fit the thesis and it goes off and becomes a billion dollar opportunity and you don't like kick yourself for that right? Yeah.

That is very true and we have in our investment committee. Meetings are very open, very Frank.

Key. It's what's the best idea? And what's the best decision on the table? And my partners in the other investment committee members? Keep us very honest. They keep us focused in what we're doing.

Double Quick stats may be helpful, yeah, 20 years ago and we started this. There were about a quarter million. Distributors internet comes along. Everybody is afraid that the internet is going to disintermediate all sale distribution.

Changes the value. Add that you now need to look to a distributor distributor, maybe 20 years ago, the key value items. They can buy boxes and break them into each has and sell them effectively Hmm. Amazon. Kind of took that whole that whole thematic approach and that's no longer it's table Stakes.

Now, there are, but it's not true value, add in which you have to do today. There are almost 250,000 everything in this room.

25:00

Yeah. Yeah, I'll lead to the plants the lamps. Everything is probably come through a distributor. Yeah. So the world of distribution has morphed the level and type of value. Add is different than it was 20 years ago but they're still 250 thousand Distributors out there and there are 109 sub-sectors of distribution.

Again, it could be carpet, distribution can be lighting, electrical distribution Healthcare. So we will look at any of those hundred nine sub-segments, regardless of the economy was going on. To find those jewels in those gems. You know we use a term we're looking for the tallest midget, sometimes we try not to chase the shiny objects.

Yeah, we stay in the areas that were very comfortable with because we know that we can truly add value.

We've seen situations where there are companies and investors and certain companies with their coming in and it's here's what you're going to do. You know, mr Owner. And you're going to do this because our Playbook says that and that's a pretty quick way to destroy value a company.

So out of all the businesses we look at because this is all we do 70 or 80% of what we see where there's a Sim and through management presentations and intelligence, we get comfortable with very quickly. Hmm. So we can focus all the time that, you know, was a private Equity Firm that we have our time as well as capital.

So we can focus on the 20% that is nuanced, different world, different things in. That's what we spend time getting comfortable with because we don't have to go in and ask during your due diligence process or imagined presentation. You know, why do you use that Erp? Or what does that Erp? And right?

Tell me about the CRM thing.

So we understand how these nice work. Yeah. And we get to focus on the Nuance part that really makes a success the opportunity for a successful investment. Yeah, that's such a great distinction that the operational due diligence that these funds have to go through to get comfortable with the sector first and then sort of the Dynamics of the sector.

I mean, there are some sectors where you just don't see a lot of contracts and and folks who play in that sector. And I'm not saying it's the one you play in. But I have seen it were the folks were know who know the industry. You know that that's these are just table Stakes. These are the rules of engagement.

If you want to play here, these are the stakes and and the rules.

If you can't get comfortable, then you shouldn't be playing. And I think that's the part that can be frustrating for someone like us. Whereas, like, we disclose this, we told you about this, like, you needed to get comfortable on the front end. We should not have bid on it and someone who understands how the industry really works.

And you can, you basically can cut that operational diligence in half or even more. So, because you are already comfortable with that. Tree long before you showed up, right? And of course, you do, and you invest in backing, of course, your job is to get the best deal for your clients.

Well, yes, a deal is not just price its price and structure in certain Q, close to the process. Yeah, and, you know, we have seen times in which, we have not been successful at the very end. We in even wee bit Uh, pricing. We think is very aggressive, even sometimes based on aggressive growth opportunities that we are comfortable, and because we have, Have been there and seen that in done that before Yeah.

And somebody comes on top, I like a turn or two of you both are and we're going. We don't see how a firm will ever make money and the owners will call us and say, can you please? Yeah Right. Please meet this project because we really want to work with you supply chain Equity You do this deal.

We said we don't understand that. We'd love to work with you and can't.

Three years ago when the owner called, and he called about six weeks. After the deal was closed, is when we didn't win, it was that situation Dara and he says, dog on it and used a different word that is on it. He goes for weeks in, they've told me, I have to reduce my staff. You look dollars by about 23%.

All the growth initiatives were working on, have to go away.

And here's what they're going to do blahblahblah and I would never say I told you so but sometimes sometime sometimes. Some things can be too good and it's a balance and I understand it as we're selling a business, we want to sell a business that we own, that is going to be good for the management team.

We would never sell a business into a situation where the buyer is looking at this businesses to what they can cut, right? They can do we just we just won't do it because we're always looking from the management perspective. Is is this the best opportunity for the business going forward?

See it's interesting Market out there. So I was born outside of Boston. In Massachusetts, we have a saying sometimes the matter guy wins. So in private Equity, sometimes the fund who needs the deal. The most is, the one who wins and I think in this world that we're in now today, there's so much Capital chasing so few deals where there is going to be a fun that's been around for 18 months that has yet to done it, to do a deal and they have to deploy.

They just have to, they need to start putting money to work and start doing deals and if they don't, they have no chance of rain.

30:00

In the next one, we've seen fun start giving money back to LPS without deploying so I think that's what you saw there Unfortunately. It's just it's a dynamic in the market that is sort of abnormal, but an unfortunate and it is without delving into that.

It's an unfortunate situation because the LPS don't know what's going on, right?

Acura of a really good return for LPS. Just isn't there, you know, unless you out like five sigma's and you happen to get lucky out there, you'll please don't realize it. And by the time, they realize that they've already committed to the next month right in there on. It's, it's just, it's just a an approach.

We just don't take and help. Ease is limited partners, right? So I did, we part of what we do here is demystify the language of MMA and LPS are limited partners Other ones. Who invest in the fund, they put the money together.

EPA, the general partners of the ones like Jay who invest money on behalf of these investors. And I think that that Dynamics important to explain. It's a strange world that we're living in. No doubt. I want to go back to a point. You made about you listening to The Operators on when it is time to exit.

Because that's a, that's a unique sort of view on on how to do this. As, you know, again, you've got LPS limited partners who are expecting a return. They don't invest in these things in these funds. To just be, you know, good folk, they're demanding a return, you know, two three, you know times multiple on invested Capital so they are expecting your return.

So talk a bit about about that Dynamic if you don't mind sure.

He's kind of the short tail on that and a long ago on that. So to your point, we have limited partners.

Is what's the right hole here so classically in private Equity. They'll there's always been a discussion about you invest in day one, you work the first year and a half to two years to quote unquote, add value that year. Three, you prepare a business for sale and you're selling it in about your Force? Yeah.

Now, that's changed a lot in the last few years, old periods, or a lot longer, but that's been the normal Cadence of private equity in a normal, in a normal world or investors.

It may not be three or four years and maybe five or six, sometimes it, maybe seven if we're truly in a situation where we think that we can continue to add so much value and grow the equity value this company, that much more about continuing to hold on to it. And that's where those extensions come in and and that's what allows us to have that flexibility to go out longer where we think it's appropriate.

We've actually I think the best situation that comes to mind is we had an investment in a business and their top seven or eight customers made up, probably about 75% of the business and it was pretty well skewed amongst those top, but they customers they had a very strong, the company had a very strong value proposition in there.

These were decades-long relationships, it was a reason for them to be the reason for the company to be in there.

A lot of risk up and down there, 18 months down the road, those seven or eight Consolidated into three. So they were buying each other up and all of a sudden we went from a situation in, which you could talk to each one of those companies every year to get different product lines.

Most like a lineup review, you different product lines into their company. Now, the seven or eight went to three and they're bidding out every product line with five year contract. So you win for five years, will you lose for five years? The CEO called, I happened to be chair of that board.

See called called me up. And he said, look, this world has changed faster than we've ever seen. This is a second generation business dark and he goes. Yeah, my dad never saw anything like this. I never saw anything. Like just, we need to align ourselves with this kind of party. If we're going to be successful, we need to look to go out now.

And then we end up selling that business in less than a little bit less than three years ago because our owner was a student. The yeah, the president was stood enough to help us understand Yeah. What that market was looking like it was in the best interest of that business to go sooner rather than later.

It's a really interesting story side. Your they really informed the timeline and even the approach which is, which is smart, the you guys listen. So a lot of funds are doing different sort of tactics, to employing, different tactics to keep hold of a business that they're not ready to sell.

We're seeing continuation vehicles to some degree.

Miss application, I would say, I think some of the early ones they sort of take all the dogs in the portfolio and throw them in a

35:00

continuation vehicle and dupe some some new set of investors so that wasn't necessarily the purpose of them. I'm curious what your take is on a continuation vehicle.

Really good question. I think sometimes that vehicle is Tainted by exactly what you said, it's what used to be. But I think now we're seeing because, you know, the whole periods of gone from an average of three and a half to four years. Yeah, seven years now to Korea just in the last five years or so.

Yeah. So now you have a lot of funds as you were talking about that are very long in the fund, they would like the hold the business longer, it may be a very good business. They just can't their your 7, their urinate. They have to provide liquidity to their investors in those cases, it can be very good.

Mmm, in a good situation.

In other cases, in which a decision may be made to sell a business and maybe just hasn't been performing and just to get out of that, you know, that's the other side of it too. So I think investors just have to be very prudent. We get calls my partners and I get calls, you know, almost a weekly, but by every two or three weeks, I'm instituting.

Tutions. They're saying, I'm looking at this continuation vehicle for this distribution business. Tell us what, you know, about the industry and what, you know, about the market. And about this company is specific to help us really decide if it's a good investment for us or not, they're a lot of funds out there really struggling.

I've seen some vintage funds from the encoded that I have dpi's dividends paid in capital, which is one way to measure how successful a fund is it returning Capital to their investors. Below like word for like really pitiful ones, you know, six years. That's that, those are, those are tough.

And I even talked about sort of standing up a fund, like myself inside of Benchmark to go by institutional positions, in these funds, who need to return Capital. But have good companies, that's the conundrum. I think there are some that have some bad investments in that just is right.

But there are some great companies that they overpaid for, right, that they need to return capital for that man.

That I looked at 20 plus years ago in Venture when I was in Venture. I so I was too young to, you know, I was in my early 30s. I couldn't pull together the kind of capital to put together that fun. But I had the idea and it seems like it's that's a huge opportunity now in private equity.

And and there's actually a lot of that going on now. Dara, because it was, it's more institutionalized now than it was even five years ago.

But four, five, six, seven, eight years.

To buy these longer tail longer, hold businesses to try to provide some liquidity, which really changed in the last four or five years is. It's now an Institutional Equity glass, you can go and you can buy into a fund whose job is only to buy secondaries. And that's all that they do provide that liquidity and sometimes they're getting actually.

I-i've actually invested in one of those myself just personally and I've seen in some of the returns of starkly. You've been very good.

Investment in a fund that's holding the fund up from getting to their next to their next fund. And sometimes there are there a good value opportunities to be had there?

No doubt, I think that's an interesting one and I guess I missed the opportunity but that is such as well. Like, the other thing you were heading to time there so I didn't have the ability to pull it together but so I want to shift a little bit here to sort of more of a macro perspective and I think, you know, I love doing this sort of the macro to micro conversion conversation

The perfect person have that talk about the impact of the macro macro forces on, on rudimentary like root Industries in this country. I think there's been a bit of a retrenchment and like a focus. Now, on some of these old world businesses that are so critical to us, and there's some Trends, obviously, that are impacting, you know, the manufacturing supply chain, the distribution channels significantly and and I've talked about in this podcast, probably more than a pipe.

Bored people with my view on sort of globalism and the death of globalism engine is it going away as a as a as a huge part of the supply chain? I mean I when I was sort of getting out of college a long supply chain meant like an efficient Jeep supply chain and like you could you know you get something out of China and it shipped here and then seven steps later ends up, you know, in a consumers hands and it created a very cheap supply chain but that required like a focus on globalism.

Are the US Navy patrolling all the all the waterways which we did starting in World War at the end of World War Two. When are you will never thought about that? They need it all. That's right Exactly. So we had a Navy that was largely intact after the war where the only one. So we basically guaranteed you know free trade we said okay but if Russia gets you know a little a little antsy like we're in a throw you in front of Russia.

40:00

And they're like, sure you love us to be a part of your Global Supply Chain.

We kind of killed that recently and so there's a real focus on on shore. During and nearshoring. And that's my God, that's got to be, you have to be salivating over the some of these strategic opportunities because you know that that Focus you're sitting there kind of poised and ready and have capital in your hands ready to deploy any thoughts on that?

It is I mean, the most massive change that I've seen in my career. Hmm. And and the rapidity of that is just almost scared. Yeah, quick aside, we look at a business about four years ago.

Importing about 70% of their product from China. There's a specialty sensor and it did like 23, special things and it was a really great business. They had no Second Source or any of that. This was just when the Tariff starting to hit and all of a sudden their cost of goods sold went up by 30% Course it did.

Now if everybody else is buying from China and this example for that product line, if in-store, yeah, but the competitors happen

And their class was going up and we have to talk to the selling private Equity Fund. That we know very well and said, we think we can partner with you and help through this, but we're not sure who's going to give you a clearing price on this because the uncertainty is just too much and it just, it happens in them overnight.

And I think the better very educated public probably listening to this podcast, but the average person on the street, doesn't truly appreciate how these rapid changes have impacted. So many companies that are out there. Tariffs. Think about it overnight? Your cost of buying something can go up and to 50% or 100% Right?

How do you price that?

How do you work on that? What happens if all of a sudden your supply chain goes from 6 weeks, X, China, and four weeks before that, to manufacture something, to we think we can get it in four months, maybe, we're not sure, because the Red Sea is closed in the straight over here is closed, and we can't do this.

So, tariffs supply chain, disruptions all of that as impacted almost every company. Now, ourselves and distribution supply chain your point, it does bring up some opportunities Mmm.

We think we have some insight into some of the areas that can be of interest. So, think about it. Once you've got a long supply chain, everybody was running into just in time fast, there's very limited buffer inventory anywhere the system. So now in the last few years, people have realized, we need that bufferin retort.

So what does that mean? From an investment perspective?

You need more. Last Mile transportation and some minimal Transportation. Intermodal becomes very, very important. Now, as you move in between warehouses, yeah, good Amazon's done. They built this massive distribution Network around around the world, that's just unprecedented. Yeah, and they've done that, you know, they were didn't do that because of tariffs and disruptions.

They just wanted to be faster in, delivering the customers. And so, they bulletproof themselves. It did and doing what they're doing. So that's your major change. Reason Barn distribution centers, Transportation Logistics, warehousing in those areas. And then you have to think very carefully.

What are those warehouses? For example, serving is a cold storage that may be a different investment thesis. Then just a big box to store pens and pencils. In example. So you have to think about what the end markets are doing sometimes the applications in those and markets, the determine if you think that's a good investment or not but it's turned everything on its everything.

On its back.

We basically have to double our manufacturing base here in this country and we need to kind of do it yesterday. And I think one of the things I believe is that we're going to see these smaller manufacturing facility stood up versus the big traditional ones. And I think you know very much automated at almost has to be but they require power.

They require HVAC a lot of that stuff and they require capital and you know six trillion dollars going into AI infrastructure spend

Them. Requiring so much power and so much, you know, the mechanical, you know, capacity. I'm really curious how we're going to make both of these go with maybe not as much Capital available. I saw we saw this 25 years ago in fiber or, you know, at which is why China became such a big thing that all too well, because we did manufacture, we said, well, let them into the this was a global supply chain in the World Trade Organization.

We shifted everything over there. We didn't have Capital but facilities up then because we're about messing. Everything in the fiber back then. It sounds very familiar. I'm really curious what your view is. I sort of like how we're going to navigate these Waters where there's not as much Capital going into standing up these manufacturing facilities that we need and the power and Mechanicals that we will need to make these facilities.

45:00

Actually flourish the human capital that we need a you know, we we've got a straw, a tougher immigration policy. We need more folks to help stand these facilities up. It's a really interesting cocktail that we're going to have to figure out how to how to pour it is. And I think we all saw yesterday, the FED increased of the rates short-term rates by 25 Pips, The Fed funds rate by 25 bibs, you know?

So, and now it's trade. Can the 10-year up to today almost 5%? Yeah. Which is what mortgages are based on. Yeah, so the average consumer is feeling in a car loans, and mortgages and the else. And so part of it is inflation Yes. But part of what's driving, inflation is exactly what you said, our and that is, there is so much demand for products that are going.

Into these AI centers and these other areas, they're competing for Capital and when you've got a restriction on the amount of capital

but second to do it's going to raise the price and cost of capital. And that's exactly what we're seeing is one of the major drivers what's going on. Now the good news of it is the other thing you mentioned and that is it's pulling manufacturing back into this country It is. So because Supply chains are now less stable, how do you deal with that?

Well, you can have lots of buffer inventory. If it is it different stages in your entire supply chain or you can bring the source of it all the manufacturing here, right?

If the raw materials are in the u.s., it's even the even better because you get access to that but maybe you just import some raw but you're doing the final assembly and test the higher value. Add right, you know, our country is likely, never going to be back to making sneakers where some place in the world.

Someone's getting a dollar and a half an hour to do that. Mmm, that's not the level of value add want. So, we love to see me. Manufacturing come back.

I mean before I got in our crazy world Dara, I'm an engineer by undergraduate and back to business school later in life, but I grew up in the world of Automation and electrons and and the up running two or three, pretty substantial businesses before I moved into Investment Banking.

And I just have a heartfelt love for making stuff. Yeah. In manufacturing stuff and we're starting to see that coming, you know, coming more and more into the United States, but because

Value, you have to compete with lower cost manufacturing other places the world. Even with the higher-value paper products, like I said, we're never going to make lower value of sneakers. But even the higher value, sometimes, you can throw 10. People is something that maybe one robot condemned, maybe those 10 people over in Pakistan or less expensive than a robot, right?

But that starting, that number is starting to switch over with that transition is. So now we're seeing plants come up but they're not coming up with you.

I've been before maybe they're 80 people and the using automation to help get the net final cost down to where they can compete not just in the US but no Global basis. So, we are if you walk into a plan today, you'll see something in a lot of plants called Cobalt and Cobalt stands for collaborative robot.

Yeah. So there's literally like the top part of a person but it's all robotic Yeah.

At work or some other things. But sometimes you may have a line of cobots with various people. Interspersed sometimes beginning of the end and sometimes in between those going from cobots to full robots. If you go to an Amazon Center, you'll see name of that kiba's. The company they bought many years ago, we have these little robots that it's called Goods.

The persons that a person too good. So the robot will go into the warehouse, get the goods. Bring it to the packer.

And the Packer, then there's all the stuff they do. Jobs in the Box were historically. That Packers been person to Goods that person has to go into the warehouse, if all the various parts and then bring it back. So you've got robots, like, the old Kiba robots. Now they're doing that your robots that are just working next to a human being walking, the aisles.

And is some, he see a bin and it's a cart and it turns a light on and says pick from a 3-1 or combination of that all the way through complete lights out.

Warehouses using what's called asrs, automated storage and retrieval system.

We're literally has lights out Yeah. It's like a big giant Cube and Matrix that nice Pickers these slides are just moving all around. It's like, it's like watching something from the Matrix. It's incredible. I've seen I've seen some of the videos but it'll let us compete. Yeah. And bring more and more and more manufacturing back to the US, but it's going to be a higher level manufacturing and higher value at.

So I love talking macro to micro, it's one of my favorite things to talk about having you on it. That's why I wanted to dive in, but I think having you on also is useful for an audience of business owners and their spouse to sort of understand your perspective, on the things that they can do to ensure that they are best prepared or process for a sale process.

50:00

So if you, if you were to impart some wisdom on them, but you know, what would you say, sort of a couple years in advance, what would you advise a seller to consider in advance of a potential transaction?

Really glad you asked that question. Because for your listeners here and Watchers as a business owner is probably the most important thing to be considered. Mmm, so we talked a little bit about how my firm is a private Equity company. We have somewhat of a Playbook that we just optimized for the specific situation but we didn't talk about how we evaluate whether they want to buy a business or not and how much we're going to pay for the bill Yeah yeah.

A checklist that we go through there as well.

And you know, let's let's spend a few minutes and talk about that. But what I will share with the audience in terms of some of those back boxes that we and other private. Equities go through any seller. This looking to sell the most important thing they should be doing is years in advance, thinking about when they're looking for an exit and thinking about what investors are going to be looking for and what the red, not just what will position them well but what Will potentially really hurt a sale.

What takes value away on them? And think through what they can do over? It could be six or 12 months. It could be three or four years to close those gaps. So, the time they do go out and in a private Equity Firm, or an investor, is looking at that business and thinking through, do they have this?

They not have this?

They are really well positioned. They've got a higher certainty of clothes when a deal and they're going to get a higher price in a better structure at the end of the day. So those of you listening that are owners think about things such as concentration. Yeah, the biggest thing we see I can't tell you how many businesses we've looked at over the years dollar where it's a really nice business but it has one big problem and it's the owner who controls everything Yeah.

Yeah. All the major customer relationships have had to go through that owner Yep. All the major vendor relationships are with that owner.

It's an exceptionally, familial environments. Everybody looks that owner for every decision. You really don't have a well-functioning executive team because I don't want to wants to make all the major.

And by the way, that owner is now 72 and wants to cash out and retire.

Other than that, that type of business could be a very good. Be an attractive business in the right situation.

But you just have to walk away from those things In those things. We just literally unsalable where they do get sold its in a structure and price. That the owner really just doesn't find attractive. It's got you journals and so they purr and, you know, but if that owner has thought through, how do I get ready and I made those Investments, how do I look at?

Customer concentration, how do I specifically Diversified Custom Creation? How do I work to diversify vendors? Yeah, if I don't diverse. By then just do. I have a second vendor and a third vendor that can step in what is my management team look like, do I have an IT structure? That is scaled.

Now, maybe if it's an add-on that business is an add-on, that's less important. So whether it's an add-on or a platform that maybe we can chat about, I think makes a big difference there, but it's going through those checklists of things that we look for in a business that they should be thinking about in advance, and closing as many gaps as they can.

You make them more attractive. Make sure they don't have any of the check boxes that are Big Red's and say like the example, I gave you with the owner that it just becomes unsellable disk.

Yeah. Those, we talked about that a lot. It's great to hear someone who does it every day. Say it and not just an empty suit like myself. But the notion of like pushing down these relationships, creating functional ownership in places that are not the owner, and then giving them decision rights, giving them the ability to make decisions on.

On different functions. And the test I always say, is, can you go on a six-week River, Cruise in Europe and the business doesn't feel it. And if you can, that's a pretty good test. That you've got a business that's going to be. That's going to survive you in that business. That's so founder.

Dependent is probably worth half the business that is. Got a depth of leadership or is like the owner is there as sort of a figurehead maybe an inspirational or sand signs, a lot of the

Sales call. And when in this moved, it moved that sort of ownership across the business we worked with your teams over the years Darrow and you had that that that's how you guys operate. Give a real quick aside our lead investor in our first one is supply chain. Equity was a business that we had sold when we pitched that deal as investment bankers.

55:00

20-plus years ago.

It was electrical distributor, I won't go any deeper than that. We sat in front of the team and you had the very he had a tremendous, chairman and is his other owners and around the tables are very formal setting. He was a very much of a southern gentleman.

We sat down and I had the pleasure of leading that pitch at the time and I stood up and I said, you know, mr. So-and-so because we want to cover today about, let me get two. A punch line, our recommendation is going to be that you do not sell the business today.

We believe from our due diligence and our knowledge of distribution. And that's all we do did as investment banker. Like we do now, we said we think there's an opportunity for you to do a b c and d that would double the equity value of your company

and we said double because actually what our calculations soldiers but I'll still remember I'll never forget the moment. Direct took his glasses off, he tapped him on the table.

You should let me understand something, you're an investment banker. Correct I said yes, sir I am. He goes after glasses, couple more times goes in, you really only get paid when a company is sold. So yes sir That's correct.

And he goes and your recommend you to me that I not sell my company.

Writes it? Yes Or no. If you choose this out your company want to be the we want to show you that we we think we're the best in the market but that that is our recommendation.

Because I put his glasses back on. You, we went through and through our pitch.

We must have went the last Bankers in. I assume is we agree with you and you get us these couple consultants in to help us do these things as we haven't done them before.

And let's see what we can do.

The turnaround, was that quick that in about 10 or 11 months? We got a phone call back.

And now there's no bake off now called us as the investment bank, right? This is yours. Let's go out and do this random process.

What was going to be about 20, 25 million of equity and into 80 or 85 Oh, wow, honey. Okay, bye person doing that. So to me, that's the best example that individual by the way, was our lead investor in fund one. That's all hygienically. What a story. He's probably still at.

Well, we're always be thankfully.

So I'm curious sort of what your your philosophy is on. You know, Finding leadership traits in you in specific Investments. I mean, it's a big part of your rubric to say is this is this a leadership team that we can back and support? Are there certain characteristics that you look for?

There are in part of. It depends on whether it's an add-on acquisition. We may not need right everybody In that role. We still want to keep the people, maybe their roles. Change worship lat.

Give us a new platform business upon which you want to bring add-ons on and really this the mothership. So to speak the mat, the executive manage team is correct, absolute critical. Particularly the person that's going to lead the business and run that business because all we do is distribution.

It's Not Unusual for us to work with an executive team. But, let's say, you know, we've had a great sales team. We have great here, but we need you don't have a true c00 that we really need.

On this platform. And we also need just spitballing here. We need, we need a better idea thing because the IT world is changing.

We can we can help bring those people in because we can find people that know how to do that in distribution. That are proven individuals began That's all we do. And so our Network 20 years, so it doesn't have to be a complete full team, but we need to know that we can work around.

Work with that team to make it a complete full team.

Characteristics. It's trust. First and foremost you can't trust the people around the table. You got the wrong about the wrong people. Yeah we were looking for the highest degree of Integrity looking for people that want to make decisions based on data not just gut

feel and it won't have good. Open debates, hmm. Where it's not a matter of who's right or wrong, but let's collectively, get around for the important issues and debate them in this in the best.

The best idea in the best decision wins Yeah.

Going forward. That's really where we look for the team, but that team is critical Number one's eyes. And when you're doing a deal, do you sort of craft a bespoke, you'll structure to the situation team, the deal? Or do you have a preferred structure that you like, hey, we like, we require 20% rollover, Equity, retained equity, and every deal a.

Is it much more bespoke and sort of purpose-built for that situation and deal?

2:00:00

It is very bespoke. We start with the folks that are in a driving Valium. In the business president, his key executive team were assuming they're all driving value.

If the president, maybe someone the rolled over equity and they've been the prior owner.

So we want them to have a stake in a rollover, some Equity into the business.

And I'll know if you're if leadership your viewership understands that but if you're paying a hundred million dollars for a business, you want that owner now to keep going forward and running as president like that own into invested chunk of that hundred million dollars. That's meaningful that person so that they're still not sleeping at night because we're counting on that person to make the decision.

Yeah, run the business course, we want everyone around that executive table, either own Equity, we give them all opportunities to own.

We also put in place profit-sharing Yeah. So is there helping and driving the creation of value? Then they also get a piece of that. We also take profit sharing in deeper than the vast majority of private Equity Funds. If a business is dependent on outside sales team going to sit down with that outside sales, team and find the way to get Equity or Equity like instruments in their hands.

If it's super dependent upon this incredible, product Management, Group in such, we're going to try to get equity in their hands as well.

Be driving this business.

I'm have have top incentives that that's important. And we want the dollars to be meaningful. Yeah, man.

And which meaningful for someone that just got a hundred million dollar check? Yeah, is different than someone that is never had it a liquidity event.

As long as this meaningful, we are very flexible in working with we say in this podcast, the best way to make people act like owners

B shares, we've options, we've seen all kinds of different Vehicles use but if you want them to act in the best interest of the Enterprise and you have to give them the upside of, of the efforts that they that they contribute. And I think something else. At least, we do a little differently that your viewers from a finance resting when there's actually stock involved, we have never had preferred stock.

Okay, everybody has stock is the exact same class. Okay, Zack. Same type of shares that we have. So we want to, you're just so wanting to make certain that everyone is aligned on those.

Together, you don't see pair pursue like that very often. That's only where we do deals in a banana.

So as we sort of wind down, I do like to ask a question where you actually take this seat. Now, you don't have to actually get up and take my seat. But if you were sitting in my seat and you had someone in that seat, that was a be contemplating selling a business. What would be the question?

Appropriate. If you can answer that question. Once your what you've asked it, this is no no that's contemplating a sale at the point of sale or you could even take someone who actually are has already sold the business. But something that would inform our audience members, if you get a chance to ask that question by the first thing I would ask is why are you selling and what do you want to do today at? Hmm.

Okay. You see a lot of folks that they'll sell their business and let's say they want to step into a board role.

Well, that board rules non-operating rule. Yeah, so, they're used to coming in with 50 emails at 6:00 in the morning that turn into 200 emails. They're, they're used to the Cadence and the decision making and everything else. And they step in the office on Monday morning, they may still want to keep the office there as a board member and life is completely different and they hadn't thought through that.

Yeah. So I'd encourage that person sitting in that seat to say what you want to accomplish, where are you and your career and your life,

Trying to accomplish. And then think through putting the money aside, we're assuming it's recording, the event will probably set you up for Life. What do you want to be doing the next day after that transaction done? And talk about talk about that with the investor from day one.

You are, you want to be a board? Member, are you comfortable? Do you want to have more of an opportunity role and think through all of that? So the day of transaction is announced you who have grown this business and own this business.

It's very clear to the rest of the organization. What your role is going. Going to be, and it's something that you are looking forward to. And you've thought through, I think that's the most. That's the first question that I would ask much to me. And that's, you know, it's day one of your posts supply chain Equity career, right?

So you know, they're raising fun nine and he decided, you know, I don't think I want to go through it again. You know I've hit a certain point in my career, my life.

What is day one look like for you. Post supply chain Equity. That's interesting. Well, I am a. You ask the questions.

It's interesting because it was your question I haven't given it back to you. All right, well I mean I love what I do.

There's a grid of my wife. Yeah and it's just what I love to do.

2:05:00

So I think what I would do when that day comes is probably some board work boards that are give me a chance to have real input not just for governance in that case. And Frankly, Speaking I would love to be advising owners of businesses and how to prepare the business well in advance for sale because there's so much value.

Available there. Yeah, that I see being left on the table. I to me that would be a fascinating, you know, value-adds of a whole community and helping folks, get the most they can get for the business with the best pricing structure and certainty of closing and be able to achieve their specific objectives because their investment bankers and their private Equity is really nobody in the middle of it helps share the views of both in sometimes the maybe

We're Equity Fund the, you do as an investment banker, it really takes a little thought because it's your perspective may be different than mine. Yeah.

But if there's someone that can help guide that owner through the trade-offs and here's why the darkness team is saying that. And here's why your buyers are saying this, but here's what they're really trying to get to and here's what you get through. That would be a very rewarding next step for me personally.

Yeah and my answer is very similar to that and I think we both have been sort of on that investment banker side.

Deploying of capital into businesses and Leadership roles and businesses. So I have got a very similar question answer. So when you're ready to do that, you give me a call and we'll see. We'll see if we can attack that problem together, down the road Sounds good, what? I appreciate you come in, and this has been fantastic and I really appreciate all your insights.

I think we talked, we tackled some areas that we probably haven't gotten into very much in the past. So thanks for coming in. Well, thanks for the opportunity. We appreciated our and remember in business and in life, best outcomes aren't found. They're built.

Far too many business owners, go into the most impactful financial transaction of their lives. With both arms, tied behind their backs.

That's because they're operating at a severe disadvantage.

Most business owners sell precisely one time once.

So not only do they not know the answers in many cases? They don't know the questions to ask and that isn't their fault.

MMA has a language of its own and no one has made a mission of ensuring business. Owners are as informed as our advisors, and the buyer on the other side of the transaction.

Until now this podcast exists to serve that Gap.

Well, we can only fulfill our mission if this show finds those who could most benefit from its content, so please help us find those people.

If you like this podcast, let us know.

And let the world know, hit the like button. Tell us what you learned in an episode or what you want us to cover. Next subscribe. Share it with someone who needs it. Help us close that Gap.